GAMBLERS OF THE WILD WEST
by Bill Kelly
PHIL COE: POKER GENIUS AND WILD BILL HICKOK VICTIM
A Texas dandy, Phil Coe was the prototype of the
Hollywood Western gambler; elegantly dressed, with
evenly trimmed beard, ivory-headed cane and derby hat.
He was a man whose heart was as warm as a hanky soaked
in ethyl chloride.
Unfortunately, history will remember him solely in
relation to the man who killed him. His killing by
City Marshal Wild Bill Hickok in Abilene, Kansas,
October 5, 1871, dulled his reputation as a phenomenal
poker
player and gunman. Having the incredulous distinction
of being Hickok's last shooting victim assures him a
place in the annals of Western archives.
Information is sparse on Coe because he charged his
story more often than he changed underwear. We know
absolutely that his father emigrated to Texas before
July, 1835, settling in present day Washington County.
Young Phil served as an officer in numerous
expeditions against Indian attacks. He made a gallant
show of
himself in the skirmish with Mexico.
The skeletal record of Coe's years in the military
reveals that in late 1862 he joined Captain William
Tobin's company that replaced Company "F" of the
original 2nd Texas Cavalry. It was here that he
became immediate friends with another famous-to-be
gambler and gunfighter named "Terrible" Ben Thompson.
Both spent their lifetimes as professional gamblers.
Both died fighting viciously for the spoils of their
forage.
After the war they became traveling gamblers, drinking
to access and choosing their victims from hotels,
casinos and other places where good-time Charlies
congregated. By the 1860s Coe was already a fixture on
the gambling circuits. He had his reminiscences
ghost-written by Floyd B. Steeter, who wrote that he
and Tom Bowles opened a gambling casino in Austin,
Texas and Thompson and Coe were frequent card players.
Another gambler loosed on the community was a
gunfighter equal in reputation to Wild Bill Hickok or
Ben Thompson.
His name was John Wesley Hardin. At age seventeen he
was already a fugitive on the dodge during the ladder
part of 1870. His life was gambling and whoring.
Still another notorious gunfighter who sat in on
their poker games was Bill Longely, and, frequently,
Jim Brown and Ben Hinds. All three made their living
traveling from one gambling emporium to another.
Hardin wrote in his autobiography, The Life of John
Wesley
Hardin As Written by Himself.
I met a good many well-known characters on those
trips to Brenham (Washington County, Texas). I used to
gamble a good deal and it was there I got the name of
'Young Seven-up.' I met Phil Coe first in Brenham,
that notorious Phil Coe who was afterwards killed in
Abilene, Kansas, by 'Wild Bill."
Coe, Thompson, Wild Bill and Hardin were all
specialized poker players during the calamitous summer
of 1871. The only thing certain about Coe's
shenanigans at the time of his death is that he lived
on the outskirts of Salina, Kansas, near Abilene.
Though his companions were frequently notorious
rouges, he was not one himself. The memoirs of
frontiersman W.M. Walton
provides an insight to Coe's character. This is his
interpretation of the famous gambler:
Just at this time Phil Coe, Ben's old army comrade,
find and quasi officer, came to Abilene and had with
him some thousands of dollars. A line of action was
at once concluded on between him and Ben. Coe was a
man
who would attract attention in any county; over six
feet for inches high, splendid presence, frank
face, handsome as a prince, brave as a lion, generous
to a fault, faithful as a woman, positive and decisive
in action, forgetting a friend never, and yet could
forgive a foe. They at once combined their resources
and became proprietors of the Bull's Head saloon,
jointly. They addressed all their energies to the
establishment of the character of their place of
business. They were successful and had a great run of
custom. So much so that a gold mine could not have
been more profitable.
When Hardin made his acquaintance with Coe and
Thompson, in May, the Bull's Head Tavern and Gambling
Saloon was already a thriving establishment steered to
appeal to Texas cattlemen fresh off the range, looking
for an honest game of chance. Unfortunately, they were
in competition with the Alamo, the foremost gambling
palace in town. Wild Bill Hickok, who, as town
marshal, was not only guardian of the Alamo, but he
and city authorities were in colleague up to their
sombreros.
The enmity between Hickok and Coe probably began when
Coe remarked that Texas cattlemen were being
hornswoggled by rigged gambling games at the Alamo.
Calling Wild Bill Hickok a 'card cheat' was
tantamount to road rage with Mike Tyson. More
historians claim that Coe and Hickok were smitten by a
female with an hourglass figure, named Jessie Hazel.
Jessie's father was a real estate broker and she gave
lots away. It was certainly possible that Jessie's
presence added enough fuel to touch off an
explosion of rivalry that would play into the modus
operandi of the gunfighting Wild Bill Hickok.
Others say it is difficult to image that the
unpleasantness between Coe and Hickok surfaced over a
woman because Wild Bill, by all accounts, was not the
sort to weave tangled plots to goad anyone into a
gunfight.
Wild Bill had been appointed City Marshal by those
in authority on April 8, and controlled that position
until he was dismissed December 13, 1871. During his
tenure as towntamer, he improved his aim by shooting
stray dogs which were not appropriately registered. He
was paid fifty cents for each dog he killed.
The Abilene Chronicle reported that his mere
reputation and presence prevented considerable
violence in the town of grieving widows. But his
predecessor, Tom Smith, another notorious gambler of
the times, gained a more respectful reputation because
he tamed Abilene with his fists instead of guns.
Tension was further heightened between Wild Bill and
Coe by what is generally known as the Shame of
Abilene. Coe and Thompson had the front of their
gambling parlor
painted with a gigantic bull, with an embarrassingly
large genitalia. Although Abilene was overrun with
crooked gambling, drunkenness, prostitution and
dissimilar forms of debauchery, the city fathers
denounced the bull's dangling genitalia as vulgar.
Coe and Thompson on the other hand, found it enhanced
their business extremely. The Shame of Abilene was
carried all the way back to outspoken east coast
presses.
Historians differ on what happened next. Some claim
the fight started solely because Wild Bill wanted to
control the lion's share of Abilene's gambling
business. Others say as city marshal, he was impelled
to do something about it by other gambling interests
and some of the more refined citizens of Abilene.
Hardin's autobiography relates the following
occurrence: Phil Coe and Ben Thompson at the time
were running the Bull's Head saloon and gambling hall.
They had a big bull painted outside the saloon as a
sign, and the city council objected to this for some
reason. Wild Bill, the marshal, notified Ben Thompson
and Phil Coe to take the sign down or change it
somewhat. Phil Coe thought the ordinance all right,
but it made Thompson mad. Wild Bill, however, sent up
some painters and materially changed the offending
bovine.
Accounts in the Abilene Chronicle give no indication
that Coe was anything but a professional gambler and
card sharp.
True, he was au courant with guns, having extinguished
himself in the war, and during Abilene's wickedest era
nearly every proficient gambler carried a weapon of
some sort. Yet, it is doubtful that Coe felt himself
capable of standing up to Wild Bill in a gun battle.
In any event, the bubble burst on October 5, 1871. A
more exciting story would have been if Thompson would
have been Hickok's opponent instead of Coe, for
Thompson's skills with a pistol more closely matched
Wild Bill's. But Thompson was out of town when the
fracas occurred, and we will never know what the
outcome might have been. The Junction City Union,
dated October 7, gave this account: Two men were
shot at Abilene, Thursday evening. The circumstances
were as
follows, so out informant says: Early in the evening
a party of men began a spree, going from one bar to
another, forcing their acquaintances to treat, and
making things howl generally. About 8'oclock, shots
were heard in the "Alamo," a gambling hell; whereupon
City Marshal, Haycock (Hickok) better known as "Wild
Bill," made his appearance. It is said that the
leader of the party (Coe) had threatened to kill Bill,
"before frost." As a reply to the Marshal's demand
that order should be preserved, some of the party
fired upon him, when, drawing his pistols, "he fired
with marvelous rapidity and characteristic accuracy"
as our
informant expressed it, shooting a Texan, named Coe,
the keeper of the saloon, we believe, through the
abdomen, and grazing one or two more. In the midst of
the firing, a policeman rushed up to assist Bill, but
unfortunately got in the line of his fire. It being
dark, Bill did not recognize him, and supposed him to
be one of the party. He was instantly killed. Bill
greatly regrets the shooting of his friend. Coe will
die. The verdict of the citizens seemed to be
unanimously in support of the Marshal, who bravely
did his duty. Numerous newspaper accounts dealing with
the
shoot-out indicate that Hickok was playing poker when
he heard a gunshot fired outside the Alamo. Since
there was an ordinance against firing guns within city
limits, Hickok ran outside to see who fired the shot.
Coe explained that he merely fired at a stray dog.
This infuriated Hickok since he was getting paid 50
cents for each dog he killed. He reprimanded Coe for
cutting in on his paycheck. With incredible pluck, Coe
went for his gun. According to contemporary evidence,
Hickok and Coe fired at one another simultaneously. At
that instant, Hickok's deputy, Mike Williams came
running to help Wild Bill. Thinking he was being
attacked from behind, Hickok whirled and fired.
Williams fell mortally wounded. Hickok's reputation as
a Marshal tarnished, he was branded "trigger-happy"
and eventually forced from office.
Earlier in the day Williams received a telegram
urging him home to Kansas City because his wife
ailing. He had purchased a ticket on the Denver
express and was to leave in the morning. Instead his
body was shipped home in a pine box and buried on
Sunday, October 8. Hickok paid the freight. Coe's
grave today is located in Prairie Lea Cemetery, near
Blinn College, at Brenham. His passing was hardly
mentioned in the Daily Democratic Statesman of Oct. 12: A telegram from
Abilene, Kansas, to Mrs. Bowles of the city, announces
the death of Phil Coe, a citizen of Austin (Abilene).
He was killed by "Wild Bill, the terror of the West,"
a notorious gambler and desperado, at one time sheriff
of Ellsworth, in that State. The remains of the
deceased will be sent to this city. Phil Coe vanished
into oblivion, but not marble nor the gilded monuments
of kings will outlive the legend of Wild Bill
Hickok.*****