GAMBLERS OF THE WILD WEST
by Bill Kelly
LUKE SHORT: THE PRODIGAL GAMBLER
Before the Apple Valley Inn ceased to exist in California, about 1985,
several portraits of men and women who played major roles in the
making of the Western frontier decorated its walls. Among those of
note was Luke Short - lawman, gunfighter, and gambler extraordinaire.
Frank Dowler, old-time sheriff of Palmdale, California, probably won
and lost more money at the poker tables than most. He once talked
about the emergence of Short.
"Seldom did anyone make a laughing remark about his height, or the
fact that the name Short might refer to his shortness. On rare
occasions when they did, he would jump up and snarl, "No man can
harrah me, and get away with it!" And that man would be looking into
the business end of a gun barrel."
Beneath the Apple Valley portrait of Short was a plaque, which in part
described the man as "an immaculate dresser and gentleman." "Dapper
Luke," with a breadth of outlook peculiar to the West, wore a silk
stovepipe hat, a fancy braided shirt with ruffles, and a diamond
stickpin in his tie. He was something of a beau brummel in the West
and wore a long mustache with pointed ends.
To preface his character traits, one should know his background.
The son of a sharecropper, Short was born in 1854, and in spite of
fresh Texas air, exercise, and healthy food, he remained as thin as a
whisper. He got schooling at home, and when he was 17, he joined up
with a trail heard headed for Dodge City. Because of Short's size, a
man from Nashville named Judge Stordon took him under his wing and
taught him jockeying, and an unholy alliance was born.
When Stordon thought his frail protege was ready, they headed for the
races in Hot Springs, Arkansas. Stordon also urged Short to practice a
fast-draw and straight aim, because a fast gun could mean the
difference between life and death in the deep gambling pockets that
had yet to earn a place on the map.
Short wasn't interested in jockeying, but he hewed to the circumstance
that had united him with Stordon. Gambling was part of the night life
at the hotels in Hot Springs. Short won enough races to charm the
ladies and get invited to sociable poker sessions. He became such so
adept at blackjack and poker that he won the purses of riders and
grooms in trackroom games. An opportunist, Stordon saw in Short the
instincts of a successful gambler that was later extoled by his
unlucky victims.
Posing as indolent transients, they pooled their racetrack winnings
and visited all the gambling parlors in St. Louis, New Orleans, and
San Francisco, always searching for that pot of gold. When Stordon
died of a heart attack, Short struck out on his own with a leather
gripsack filled with double eagles and a hidden pistol to protect his
investment. He wore fancy attire, and among the miners he fleeced, he
became known as "the gentleman gambler."
There had been some bad luck to curdle the good, and Short ended up so
broke that he had to sell his fancy duds, his diamond stickpin, and
even his horse. But with bandits posting themselves advantageously
along the highways, he wasn't about to part with his pistol. Returning
to the lure of the cowtowns, he worked as a bartender and part-time
house gambler.
When Wyatt Earp took his poker game 4, 500 feet above sea level, where
Tombstone lay in its heat-blistered facades, and where excited crowds
passed in and out of gambling establishments fronted by wooden
plankwalks, Luke Short tagged along. He and Wyatt visited all the
grogshops in Tombstone, and Short eventually became a dealer at the
Oriental, a gambling house partially owned by Earp.
One night in Tombstone, he was turning cards in a faro layout at the
Oriental, when an hombre named Charley Storms started to shift his
betting arrangements. "Keep your hands off my chips," said Short, as
he proceeded to give Storms a blistering tongue lashing. Storms went
for a hidden pistol, and Short's cane slammed down on his head,
knocking Charley senseless.
Short's employers saw his showdown with Storms as a lure to bring in
business. He became a full-time house gambler, and things were going
well for Luke, until one night while he was banking a faro layout a
shot crackled from an open window and went through his derby. Someone
shouted, "it was Charley Storms.
A short time later, as Short, Earp, and a few of the veteran gamblers
were playing stud poker, Short murmured to Wyatt maliciously, "Wyatt,
I'm going to kill Charley Storms. If I don't he'll drygulch me, fer
sure." "Do what you have to," Earp agreed. At that, Short threw in his
hand and emerged from the lighted saloon. As he stepped into the
street, a pistol shot rang out from a crouched figure behind a
halter-polished hitch rail at the end of the road. Short saw a
silhouetted figure streak across the street and he shot at it. The
bullet went straight through Storms' head.
Short's newly-found notoriety followed him to Dodge City and allowed
him to associate with memorable men in the gambling annals of Kansas.
His green-felt-table associates were bankers, lawyers, businessmen,
judges, and other dignitaries. But he also went on gambling blowouts
with Bat Masterson, Wyatt and Virgil Earp, and notorious gunmen like
John Henry "Doc" Holliday. The cards had turned right for Luke, he
bought the Long Branch saloon.
In 1884 Luke Short had some trouble running the Long Branch because of
business rivalry, so he left, and with his sale from the Long Branch,
opened up the White Elephant, in Fort Worth, Texas, with its luxurious
billiard room, its elaborate rosewood bar and sparkling chandeliers.
The money rolled in .
A few years later a group of underhanded business men in Fort Worth
organized the Commercial Detective Agency, which in reality was a
front for extorting protection money from saloons and gambling
casinos. The chief collector for the organization was Longhaired Jim
Courtright. Considered to be the fastest gun in Texas, his cross draw
made him equal, if not superior, to men like Wild Bill Hickok, Johnny
Ringo, and Wes Hardin. Short had no desire to brave the fire of
Courtright's awesome pistols. Just the thought of it made him as
nervous as a calf with clabbers.
But things go as fate wills.
Courtright's fearsome reputation with a gun made him a successful
collector for the agency, and every gambling joint and saloon owner
paid up rather than go against him. On the night of February 8, 1887,
he strolled through the batwings of the White Elephant Saloon to
collect from Short. Luke told him to go to hell. Courtright was
startled. "I - I'll be back," he snarled, "and you'd better pay up!"
Most of Short's friends advised him comply with Courtright's demands.
The next evening, Courtright returned to the White Elephant. Short was
running the roulette wheel. Courtright stepped through the crowd and
asked for the money. Without looking up, Short told him, "I have no
intention of paying - is that plain enough?"
So Longhaired Jim went for his gun and so did Little Luke. Short fired
a split second before Courtright's gun was leveled, and the slug
severed Courtright's thumb on his gunhand. Courtright attempted a
"border shift" of tossing his .45 from his right hand to his left.
While the gun was in mid-air, passing from one hand to the other,
Little Luke got in his second shot. The bullet struck Courtright
squarely between the eyes. David had slain Goliath.
The following day the body of Jim Courtright, gunfighter, lawman,
fireman, and shakedown artist, were borne to the Oakland Cemetery. The
funeral procession stretched a city block. The vehicles included the
hook and ladder wagon of the fire department, of which Jim had served
honorably, and that vehicle was draped in black tapestry.
To understand why the killing of Jim Courtright, the fastest man with
a gun in Texas, by the pigmy-sized gambler was so baffling, certain
details must explained. Courtright came in with his six-guns in
holsters. Luke didn't wear holsters. His gun was in his hip pocket,
and anybody knowing about gunfighting knows that a man with a gun in
his hip pocket against a gunfighter with one in a holster has
practically no chance at all against him, even if the man with a
holster gun is a mite quicker.
His White Elephant gambling hall was packed night after night with
ogled customers who not only wanted to gamble, or see nude or seminude
girls on the stage, but also people who wanted to shake the hand of
the man who had killed the notorious Jim Courtright. Gamblers didn't
mind losing their hard-earned money, so long as they could boast that
they had sat in on a card game with the famous Luke Short.
Luke Short died peacefully in bed in Tueda Springs, Kansas, September
8, 1893. Ironically enough, when Luke killed Courtright, Jim was
39-years old; when Luke passed on, he, too, was 39-years-old.
Today the prodigal gambler and Courtright rest in the same cemetery.