GAMBLERS OF THE WILD WEST
by Bill Kelly
CANADA BILL AND THE RIVERBOAT GAMBLERS
The gamblers of the Old West were not all cavaliers of myth - and they
were not always products of the western frontier. From the 1850's until
after the turn of the century, in an era known as the Gilded Age, came
a special breed of men who suckled on the essence of gambling lore and
cut their teeth on golden legends of the riverboats. They were
compounded of the mighty saga grizzly bear hunters, leather-jacket
soldiers, and slatternly dressed merchants - far from the chivalrous
gentlemen of Hollywood legend. It is estimated that some 3,000
riverboat gamblers supported the steam packers that sailed up and down
the Mississippi into the mid-19th century.
"No group of men ever boarded the steam packers so profoundly and
widely distrusted and no one ever became more generally respected,"
observed one newspaper editor as he pondered the lives of professional
riverboat gamblers. They had to come from somewhere - the West was too
young to have many native sons. But, come he from North, South, East,
or Overseas, once a man boarded a steam packer, gambling got into his
blood. They were all atoms aiding in building an Monarchy.
At first, early-day bluenoses of society considered them a menace,
corrupt men who would kill those they could not hoodwink. It was a
familiar tale in many parts of the West of the gambler who was thrown
overboard or left stranded on a sandbar - unless he had made a prior
"arrangement" with the captain. But gradually they became an asset to
those boat operators with financial difficulties. It was the riverboat
gamblers, they realized, who drank whiskey and filled their tills
during long-night sessions of card playing. In 1858 a published
article took note that the liquor tab for the card players in one
10-hour session was $791.50.
They became not only an extraordinary attraction for boat operators,
but for dime novel writers as well. To the bored, frontier housewife,
imprisoned in remote log cabins and ranches, and puritanical mid-19th
century towns, the riverboat gambler became a romantic hero in contrast
to the bone-weary, pedestrian, hard-working men who encircled them.
Suddenly, gamblers were welcomed aboard and treated with the utmost
respect. Now they dressed up in hand-made shirts of delicate Shantung
silk from Japan - so fragile they were unable to withstand the rigors
of ordinary laundries. In time, they became so popular that their lives
were discussed by many with as much dynamism as the gunfighters and
badmen who roamed the rowdy cowtowns. Their existence was almost
paralyzing.
Granted, myth and fable have always had an incestuous relationship
with fact and actuality where the riverboat gambler is concerned.
Certainly, for all their magnification, an examination of their lives
yields the fact that many gamblers paid gratis money for the privilege
of sailing with certain riverboat captains. Many were men of evil,
ruthless cheats who didn't ply their trade on luck or skill. It is
estimated that of the 3,000-odd riverboat gamblers, a mere handful were
honest gamblers. These were men of extraordinary skill.
Dime novel writers wrote of their "smoldering dark eyes," and the
"tense alertness" that made an opponent uncomfortable. It was a
notorious fact that the top riverboat gamblers were George Devol; and
Dick Hargraves, the most successful of the honest gamblers; Canada Bill
Jones, the foremost practitioner of three-card monte; and John Powell.
Powell, a completely honest gambler, fell under considerable scrutiny
of newspaper and magazine editorials of his day.
Although Powell spent most of his time turning cards, he was a well
educated man who turned down a chance to run for Congress when his
native state of Missouri beckoned. A close confidant of Andrew Jackson
and Stephen A. Douglas, his advice was repeatedly sought by Louisiana
politicians when he was ashore in the posh home he upheld in New
Orleans.
Eyewitness accounts of Powell's three-day poker game aboard the
Atlantic, highlighted several dime novels of the early West. The story
goes that Powell won over $52,000 from the rich and famous Jules
Devereaux, a Louisiana planter. From the writer it is evident that
Powell's most flourishing years were from 1845 to 1858 when he netted
$100,000 a year. In the fall of 1858 Powell won $8,000 in four hours
from a young Englishman, who, immediately went up on deck, put a pistol
to his head, and blew his brains out. Powell was so unnerved by the
event that he returned the $8,000 to his family in England.
After that, Powell was never the cool, cocksure gambler he once had
been. It was inevitable that he would returned to the river and within
a year, go bust. John Powell, once the greatest cardshark to ever sail
the Mississippi, died in endmost poverty. In his memoirs, Tom Ellison,
a riverboat gambler, recalled: "I've seen fellows pick every card in
a pack, and call it without missing once. I've seen them shuffle them
one for one all though from top to bottom, so that they were in the
same position after a dozen shuffles that they were in at first. They'd
just flutter them up like a flock of quail and get the aces, kings,
queens, jacks and tens all together as easy as pie. A sucker had no
more chance against those fellows than a snow ball in a red-hot oven.
They were good fellows, free with their money as water, after scheming
to bust their heads to get it. A hundred didn't bother them any more
than a chew of tobacco would you.
I saw a fellow lose his whole tobacco crop in one night and get up and
never mind it particularly. Many a time I've seen a game player just
skin off his watch and ring and studs and play them in. Men often lost
their goods playing in their way bills. I've seen them betting a bale
of cotton at a crack, and it wasn't at all uncommon to hear an old
planter betting off his Negroes on a good hand. Every man who ever ran
on the river knows that these old planters used to play their lady
servants, valuing them all the way from $300 to $1,500. I saw a little
colored boy stand up at $300 to back his master's faith in a little
flush that wasn't any good on earth."
George Devol, the legendary gambler, wrote in his autobiography Forty
Years a Gambler on the Mississippi, that William "Canada Bill" Jones
was the shrewdest gambler he had ever seen. He described Bill thusly:
"...a character one might travel the length and breadth of the land
and never find his match, or run across his equal. Imagine a medium-
sized, chicken-headed, tow-haired sort of a man with mild blue eyes,
and a mouth nearly from ear to ear, who walked with a shuffling, half-
apologetic sort of a giant, and who, when his countenance was in
repose, resembled an idiot. His clothes were always several sizes too
large, and his face was as smooth as a woman's and never had a
particle of hair on it.
"Canada was a slick one. He had a squeaking, boyish voice, and awkward
gawky manners, and a way of asking fool questions and putting on a
good natured sort of a grin, that led everybody to believe that he was
the rangiest kind of sucker - the greenest sort of country jake. Woe
to the man who picked him up, though, Canada was, under all his
hypocritical appearance, a regular card shark, and could turn monte
with the best of them. He was my partner for a number of years, and
many are the suckers we roped in, and many the huge roll of bills we
corralled."
That Canada Bill was the century's greatest manipulator of cards, is
generally accepted among historians. He could show a sucker two aces
and a queen and then, virtually in the act of throwing the cards in,
palm the queen and present a third ace so that his victim could never
find the queen. Canada Bill and his partners, George Devol, Tom Brown
and Hally Chappell joined forces in 1850 and operated along the Ohio
and Mississippi for nearly ten years. When they separated, each man
had over $200,000.
What was especially notable with so many of the early gamblers was
their versatility. By the end of the Civil War riverboat companies
succumbed to the competition of steam locomotives. However, the
railroads were not as tolerant of gamblers as the riverboats were.
Three-card monte players were ousted on the spot.
In 1867 Canada Bill fired a letter off to a particularly notable
locomotive tycoon, offering a barter of $25,000 a year for the
franchise to function without being bothered. His offer was refused.
Bill and Devol continued to operate auspiciously until 1874.
Unfortunately, the travelling cardsharks lost their money as quickly
as they made it. Being gambling men, both enjoyed "bucking the tiger"
at the faro tables. It was Bill who was the originator of that
classical gambler's comment unfolded below:
Bill and Devol were killing time between boats in a Mississippi
cowberg when Bill found a faro game. He was several hundred dollars
in the hole and losing steady when Devol approached him from the bar,
and remarked, "Bill, don't you know the game's crooked!" Bill cocked
an eye, and replied, "Damn it, George, I know that. But it's the only
game in town." In 1877 Canada Bill wound up in Reading, Pa. The man
who made thousands and fleeced some of the best card players in the
world, ended up broke, having recently lost $150,000 at faro in
Chicago. He was committed to Charity Hospital and where he died. A
group of Chicago gamblers paid for his burial by raising funds by
public subscription. Thus Canada Bill was spared the final mockery.