LADY GAMBLERS OF THE WILD WEST
by Bill Kelly
BELLE STARR: THE WEST'S MOST FAMOUS FARO DEALER
At times there appeared a gambler who "stacked his
chips" on various "lay outs" from Bangor to Brazos.
He never missed a trick when it came to being crafty.
Indeed, it added to his gusto to play not only against
the luck of cards, but the talents of the other
gamblers. He was quite prepared for the double stake
- his life and his money - and of the two, held the
former as of nugatory value. Of course he kept his
pistol in prime order, sweet of pull, and
at-the-ready. There would be little excitement about
the game without drawing of cards and revolvers.
There was always rot gut liquor - always in abundance
in such gambling places. Those who ran gambling halls
seldom indludged. Novices were urged to drink long and
hearty, while the
professionals were singularly abstemious. When play
began, the inevitable result was that the intoxicated
hombre lost all his gold dust. There was always the
poor loser who sprung to his feet, his thumb on the
hammer of his Colt revolver. He had "the drop," so
to speak. Perhaps the three kings which beat his
three queens, or four treys which beat his ace full,
had become a trifle overbearing. Then there was the
table,
thoroughgoing stranger who had been dealing. In one
stretched palm of the other hand he seemed to say,
"It's all on the up-and-up, boys," That
stoical-looking man to his right was his sidekick.
It was his deal before, and alas the trick was done.
The party to the left, seated on the soapbox, had a
shrewd suspicion that in the "muss" the table might be
upset; so he covered his chips with his hands to keep
them from scattering. The old-timer, who had seen
long service, calmly puffed his pipe; he had witnessed
such shenanigans before. The noncommissioned man
toyed with his pistol. He seemed to think that trouble
was a-brewing and that if there was to be any
gunplay, "promiscuous-like," he would know whom his
pistol
should cover. The man staring into the Colt revolver
displayed a certain coolness. There was a quiet
deliberateness about his knaverly which was of the
most defiant kind. Overhead, a lamp threw a brilliant
light and accented the play of human features.
It was something that happened somewhere, practically
every day in the territories and according to the
recollections of Belle Starr, "A prospector shot a
professional gambler over a game of draw." Or "A
gambler shot a cowhand dead at poker." This was as
much a part of the old West as the sheepherders and
soldiers; the mountain men, miners, and misfits...and
the padres and the preachers. She was born on the
only daughter of Elizabeth and John Shirley, in Medoc,
Missouri, ten miles outside of Carthage, on February
5, 1848. Christened Myra Maybelle Shirley, she was
later to become known as the famous "Bandit Queen"
Belle Starr, or as noted by some historians, "Bella"
Starr. Neither way is objectionable since she signed
her name 'both' ways.
John Shirley was a bored farmer who loved to gamble
and always shifted from one deal to another. He sold
his farm and moved into town where he opened a tavern
that specialized in whiskey and cards. Shooting
scrapes, fist fights and cutting affrays were the
usual everynight deversions. Over the flip of a card,
an eye would be gouged out, or an ear chomped off. The
loser of one of these brawls would usually end up on
boot hill. Into this lawlessness the Shirley's reared
their
offspring: Preston, aged 20; Ed, aged 18, and Myra
Belle, aged 8. In time, Myra Belle could outride
and outshoot her brothers, or any other kid in the
vicinity. She attended Carthage Female Academy through
the eighth grade, took piano lessons and often
entertained by playing "Sweet Betsy From Pike," on a
Tinny piano in some gambling hall. On her off days
she
occasionally filled in as a faro dealer.
In 1863 a company of Federal Militia killed her
brother, Ed, who was leading a company of Confederate
guerillas. At this time Carthage was in ashes and the
Shirley family had rolled across the prairie country,
toward Dallas, Texas, stopping off at the present town
of Holdenville, Oklahoma, their creaking oxen-pulled
wagon bouncing through rutted trails and sinking
sandholes of dangerous Choctaw and Cherokee country.
They had to pass through Fort Smith Arkansas - a
rip-roaring, hell-for-leather town bordering on Indian
Territory. It was here that Myra Belle Shirley came in
contact with con-artists, prostitutes, gamblers,
whiskey peddlers, and gunmen, stiff-legged and
fearlessly swaggering along the plankwalks, guns
swinging from hip holsters. It was here, among this
kaleidoscopic mass of humanity, that she got the
gambling bug.
In Texas, they lived on a farm, near Scyene. The
Shirley farm became a refuge for Conferate guerrillas
whose impertinence> engrossed her. In 1866 Frank and
Jesse James rode into Sceyene with four of the Younger
brothers and made the Shirley farm their headquarters.
When the gang lit out for Missouri a few months later,
18-year-old Belle was pregnant. She had several
lovers but she claimed Cole Younger as the father of
her
illegitimate daughter whom she named Pearl Younger.
Leaving her daughter with her parents, Myra Belle
went to Dallas where she got a job dealing cards in a
saloon. In no time she became adept at poker and
raked in the money. She fared well financially as a
Faro dealer and this is how she made her living off
and on for several years.
She had been concentrating on a man who sat at her
Faro table for quite sometime. Although he was
unlucky at cards, he was daring and reckless. He was
also on the dodge from the law. His name was Jim Reed.
He called her the belle of Dallas. Thereafter, she
dropped her first name and became Belle. One night
Reed's gang took Belle out into the woods and she and
Jim Reed were married by John Fisher, another
notorious
outlaw. It was only a mock ceremony on horseback, but
Reed took it serious. He took Belle and little Pearl
to live with his parents at Rich Hill, Missouri.
They returned to Texas where Belle opened a gambling
hall in Dallas. Jim joined a consortium of outlaws led
by Tom Starr, who terrorized the Cherokee Nation and
had a standing reward on his head - dead or alive.
Belle aided the gang by keeping her eyes and ears
open about payroll shipments while dealing cards. When
murder warrants were issued against Jim, the Reeds
fled to California where they stayed in hiding for two
years. Belle's second child, Ed Reed, was born in
Los Angeles. Belle supported them by returning to her
old trade as a Faro dealer.
Jim and Belle robbed and tortured a hawk-nose, Creek
Indian who lived on the North Canadian river near
Eufala. They tortured him until he told where he had
hidden $30,000 in gold. With a posse on their tails
the Reeds swiveled into their saddles and galloped to
Dallas. Belle bought some fancy new clothes and they
visited races, fairs and gaming tables in the finest
saloons. When the Austin-San Antonio Stage Coach was
robbed, Belle and Jim were implicated and they had to
run again. Belle's parents took the children to
raise. In August of 1874, Jim Reed was gunned down by
John Morrice in the home of Charley Lee, near Red
River, Lamar County Texas. Charley Lee, accompained by
his wife and Morrice, hauled the body by springwagon
to
Paris, Texas. By the time she was thirty, Belle had
slipped in and out of many beds including that of Jim
French, Jack Spaniard, Sam Starr, Jim July, John
Middleton, Bruce Younger, cousin of Cole, and a white
man among the notorious horse thieves called Blue
Duck. While in Dodge City she loaned Blue Duck $2000
which he lost in a poker game. When he told her of
his loss she buckled on her revolvers, took Blue Duck
to the gambling bar and told him to wait outside. She
strode into the place, covered the players with her
revolvers and demanded the money back. When the
players refused
she held them up for all the money that was on the
table - $6,500.
In due time she married Sam Starr and had the audacity
to rename Sam's Glass Holler, Younger's Bend. Sam and
Belle were caught stealing horses and brought before
Judge Isaac Parker at Fort Smith. Sentenced to a year
in the Detroit penitentiary, Belle was out in nine
months. She was reviled in the Detroit newspapers as
"Queen of the Bandits," Petticoat Terror of the
Plains," and the "Lady Desperado." John Middleton had
a price on his head for killing Sheriff J.H. Black and
was on the lam. He found his way to Younger's Bend in
1884. Belle immediately became enamored with John and
he became one of her many lovers. Meanwhile Sam Starr
and Felix Griffin had been implicated in a robbery of
the Creek County treasury. A posse caught up with
Griffin, but Sam managed to zigzag his way back to
Younger's Bend. He found that his wife had ridden off
with John Middleton. They agreed to separate to allay
arrest. The plan was to meet near Dardanelle. Three
days later Middleton's horse, saddled and bridled, a
loaded .45 hanging from the saddle's horn, was found
near the bank of the Poteau River. A search party
was organized and they found Middleton's body. Sam had
shot his face off and left him in the wilds to be
eaten by wild animals and buzzards.
So Belle returned to Younger's Bend with Sam and all
was forgiven. Sam got drunk at a Christmas party and
drew on Frank West. Both went for their guns and both
fell dead almost simultaneously. Jim July, a 24 year
old Creek horse thief, moved in with Belle at
Younger's Bend. He was a wanted man. Belle made Jim
July change his name to Jim Starr. In 1889 she
convinced him to give himself up and rode with him
part of the way to Fort Smith. On the way back to
Younger's Bend she
stopped at a friend's house and argued with Ed Watson.
Neighbors reported hearing two shots near the bank of
the Canadian. Shortly afterwards, they saw Belle's
riderless horse trot past. When they investigated,
they found Belle Starr lying face down in a mud
puddle. Her entire back was riddled with buckshot.
When friends wired Jim Starr of Belle's death he
reached the Bend in nine hours. He learned the
details, and Pearl told him of the conversation she
had overheard between Ed Watson and her mother. Jim
took it from there, charged Watson with the murder of
Belle Starr, but without too much proof to back up his
story. Commissioner Brizzolars ordered Watson
released.
Watson stayed in the Territory only long enough to
collect his family and belongings, then moved to
Arkansas. Within a short time he stole a horse;
he was convicted in the Crawford County Circuit Court
at Van Buren and sentenced to 15 years in the
penitentiary at Little Rock where he escaped.
Ed Watson was finally slain by a posse of citizens
on October 24, 1910 in Florida, and serves him right.
Many historians believe that it was Ed Reed, Belle's
own son, who shot her. Shortly before the shooting
they had quarrelled bitterly over the loan of Belle's
prize horse. She had told him not to ride it, but he
did anyway. Taking up her quirt she beat the boy
unmercifully and he left home, threatening to kill
her. He was very jealous of his mother and Jim Starr
and hated them both.
Pearl Younger, daughter of Belle, married a man named
Bill Harrison but soon was divorced. It was not long
after until she had a child out of wedlock that she
called Flossie. The child was promptly put among
relatives. It was not until many years later that
Flossie found out that Pearl was her mother and Belle
Starr her grandmother.
Jim July Starr was shot in Ardmore, Oklahoma resisting
arrest in January 1890. He was buried in Potter's
field. Belle's grave today looks over the Eufaula dam
in Eufaula, Oklahoma. Pearl placed a marker at her
mother's grave with the following inscription:
Belle Starr Born in Carthage, Missouri, Feb. 5, 1848
Died Feb. 3, 1889 Shed not for her the bitter tear
Nor give the heart in vain regret 'Tis but the casket
that lies here The gem that filled it sparkles yet.